A four-step framework for CFOs to control AI token costs.

Read Now

SaaS Metrics Based Planning

Whatfix's finance lead shows how a board-level ARR target gets worked down into team budgets, and why each target should come from a benchmark rather than last year's numbers.

Last updated: November 202659 min watch

Speakers

  • Lauren Kelley, CEO, OPEXEngine

  • Amit Sharma, Sr. Director of Finance, Whatfix

  • Alok Goel, CEO & Cofounder, Drivetrain

It's the week before the board meeting. At the last one, an investor asked, by the way, what's your Rule of 40?

Now the budget is on your desk. Your CRO runs nine reps, and the plan gives sales last year's money for a much bigger number. Amit Sharma of Whatfix described that conversation: "Hey, listen, this is all the money that you have. I want you to do three times the revenue with the money that I gave you."

Two things are wrong here. First, the metrics the board values you on and the numbers your teams run on are two different lists, and nobody has shown how one produces the other. Second, without an outside reference point, every target negotiation turns into an argument about who's being optimistic.

At Whatfix, Amit said, it used to look like this:

“We used to do planning for the heck of it. It was a number that was left on an Excel sheet.” — Amit Sharma, Sr. Director of Finance, Whatfix

Amit Sharma is Sr. Director of Finance at Whatfix, an enterprise B2B SaaS company. Lauren Kelley, then CEO of the benchmarking platform OPEXEngine, moderated. Alok Goel, Drivetrain's CEO and co-founder, rounded out the panel. This article follows the method; an audience question and the full transcript are at the end.

58:32

The short version

SaaS metrics-based planning works like this: you set a target, from an outside benchmark, for each metric investors value a SaaS company on, then derive the team budgets from those targets. That way, every number in the plan has an external reference point.

  • The metrics stand in for a DCF: Growth, free cash flow, GRR, NRR, magic number, and gross margin are the components investors mostly use in place of the model.
  • Every target starts from a benchmark for your segment: Enterprise and SMB tend to churn differently, so set the number from outside data on a one-to-two-year horizon.
  • The ARR target works down into the team budgets: Amit Sharma walks through Whatfix's derivation from the board's growth number to the sales team's headcount and the marketing budget.
  • CAC is counted conservatively inside and reported the investors' way outside: Travel, tools, lead gen, and PLG costs all count.
  • Marketing is measured on productivity, not activity: Sales-accepted leads and SAL-to-close, with both heads tied to the magic number.
  • The plan is tested against valuation, with today's data: If you hit every line, what is the company worth? Start before the data is clean, because the practice shows where it breaks.

This page follows the conversation and Amit's method. For the model itself (inputs, boundary conditions, and formulas), see Drivetrain's guide to SaaS metrics-based planning.

Start from the metrics investors use in place of a DCF

When Lauren Kelley asked which metrics boards and investors actually look at, Alok said the investor's question is whether a dollar invested earns a risk-adjusted return, and arguably the best answer is a discounted cash flow valuation. However, a DCF needs free cash flow forecasts. Most private SaaS companies don't even have a free cash flow, and one that reinvests it to grow faster deserves credit for that. So, investors use proxies instead:

  • Near-term cash flow: The Rule of 40 balances actual cash flow against the growth rate.
  • Is it durable: SaaS is an annuity business, so is this growth sustainable or not? That question brought gross revenue retention and net revenue retention into valuation.
  • What it costs to produce: The magic number covers sales and marketing efficiency, and gross margin covers the cost of serving the customer.

In other words, these are the numbers the board is doing the DCF with in its head, whether or not anyone opens a model. (See Drivetrain's cheat sheet on the SaaS metrics driving investor valuations.)

Anchor every target to a benchmark for your segment

You're always going to have churn, Lauren said, and more of it in SMB than in enterprise. So, how do you balance acquisition and retention?

Alok called it the holy grail of questions. Churn is characteristic of the business (enterprise SaaS may churn less, SMB more), so it's a good idea to always start from the benchmark for your stage, model, space, and customers and back-calculate. Enterprise gross dollar retention should be something like 95%, SMB more like 85%, and the customer-success targets follow from there.

Amit raised two caveats. Benchmark against the competition, using OPEXEngine or the internet, but discount it to some extent when you start, and especially the first time through. His fear is that companies that get very optimistic will break the system, and you can't achieve your North Star overnight, so take baby steps over maybe a year or two.

So, the benchmark isn't the plan itself. What it does is let you set a target without either side having to be wrong about last quarter. (See Drivetrain's benchmarking resources for B2B SaaS.)

Work down from the ARR target one derivative at a time

How do the board's metrics become the team's numbers? Alok left the mechanics to Amit, who opened with a disclaimer: he speaks from a growth-stage company, so take the data with a pinch of salt.

Start with ARR, the growth number your board wants to chase. The next derivative is GRR. Subtract what you can renew from the number you're chasing, and what's left is what the team has to add, either through land (brand-new sales) or expansion. The third input is the expansion you predict for the year.

Next is gross margin, which shows how much COGS goes into maintaining existing accounts, assuming, as Amit noted, that customer success only does renewals. From your gross-margin benchmark, 80% in his example, derive COGS from revenue and split it by team (payroll, staff welfare, tools). Out of that comes the customer-success budget.

Then comes sales and marketing efficiency, which is nothing but the magic number. At 0.75, in Amit's example, every dollar spent on the sales and partnership team returns 75 cents, and with that derivative, it becomes easy to split the cost between marketing and sales. Drivetrain's top-down revenue planning template runs this same chain.

For the split itself, Amit's method is capacity planning. For sales, split the reps between ramping and ramped and derive the quota they'll chase, assuming all of them are in the system. That gives you the sales team's cost (see sales capacity planning). For marketing, work out what it needs to generate leads from past performance plus some uptake, a realistic marketing target, since efficiencies improve in marketing too. Plug that into S&M (for how the money is allocated inside the marketing line, see marketing budget allocation).

Every line in the cascade now derives from the board's number, which is what lets you say no to a request without it being a judgment about the team.

Plan on the most conservative CAC, whatever you report to investors

An audience member asked what the inputs to customer acquisition cost (CAC) are.

Amit said Whatfix fully loads CAC. Every team is a cost center on the ERP, and whatever gets tagged to the sales and marketing cost centers is CAC, from the reps in sales to the Salesforce license sales bought. He very openly agrees it's a very conservative way to look at CAC, and others charge a portion to G&A. Here's why he does it anyway:

…the reason I do a fully loaded conservative CAC is because I can get the true picture of what my CAC is… if I'm already doing well with the fully loaded cost of CAC, then for me to be top quartile… It doesn't come as a surprise last moment for me.
Amit SharmaSr. Director of Finance @ Whatfix

It includes lead generation, travel to customers, and rewards and recognition.

Alok said to load in every cost of getting customers, PLG and lead gen included (see the true cost of customer acquisition). Large investors may ask for CAC reported their way, he said, and you can report it on their definition, but internally, always measure it in the most conservative way.

From there, the benchmark gives you your aspirational number, you establish the baseline, and you bridge the gap. The baseline is where things get tricky, Alok added, because different teams come up with different CAC numbers.

The magic-number target in your cascade is only as good as the cost you load into it.

Hold marketing to productivity the way you hold sales to quota

Sales is pretty easy, Lauren said, with productivity, quotas, and attainment. However, marketing has a lot of activity metrics, and from a finance perspective she really likes to focus on the productivity of marketing as compared to just the activity of marketing.

Amit described Whatfix's logic as very simple. Watch for the sales-accepted lead, or SAL, which is where the rep decides whether to qualify a lead. From the SAL onward, finance tracks the funnel through the sales stages and derives the conversion rate from the top of the funnel to closure, which even in the benchmarks, Amit said, is a quite scary single-digit rate. So, the levers are to move that rate higher or to generate more, better-directed leads.

Lauren said that for targets, OPEXEngine has seen some great success with tying both the sales and marketing heads to the magic number, because then they have to work together.

We've thrown the leads over the fence… the marketing leads aren't that good… that's just not the way a modern SaaS company operates it's all collaborative.
Lauren KelleyCEO @ OPEXEngine

Once marketing has a productivity number and shares the magic number with sales, you can measure the S&M split in your cascade instead of negotiating it.

Check what the finished plan is worth, with the data you have today

Alok has been asking founders and CFOs the question:

Let's say you achieve everything that you have set out on your budget or the plan. Do you have a sense of how will your business be valued.
Alok GoelCEO & Co-founder @ Drivetrain

His recommendation is about data quality. No company has good data quality, Alok said, and people defer the fancy stuff until their data is better. But it never is, and "tomorrow my data will be better" is not a good mindset. Today is the right time. Adopt the practices Amit described, see where your data and model are broken, instrument them, and data quality improves a lot faster.

The real test of the plan, then, is whether the company is worth what the board expects if you hit every line, and not simply whether it balances.

The baseline problem from the CAC discussion, with teams arriving at different CAC numbers, is where Drivetrain does its work. As Alok described it, Drivetrain helps companies standardize their metric definitions, get data from all across the company, and bring it into one single source of truth. That way, the baseline is agreed before the benchmark sets the aspiration, and the plan maps point A to point B in a predictable manner. That is Drivetrain's SaaS financial planning software. To see it on your own numbers, book a demo today.

Questions from the webinar

Do we need to be top quartile on every metric?

Lauren said top quartile means a higher valuation on growth rate and on retention and churn, but you don't want to be top quartile in spending. The magic number is a range, not a top-quartile metric. Ideally, it sits between roughly 0.5 and 1.1 to 1.5, and above that, maybe you could invest more for an even higher growth rate, which is what you do want to be top quartile in.

Speaker spotlight

Alok Goel

CEO & Cofounder, Drivetrain

Alok Goel is Co-founder and CEO/CFO of Drivetrain, the AI-native business planning platform for modern finance teams. He holds an MBA in finance and brings deep financial expertise from over five years as a Partner at Elevation Capital, where he led venture investments in high-growth companies, rigorously evaluating business models, financial projections, and unit economics at scale. Alok also served as CEO of FreeCharge, where he executed India's largest M&A in the Indian internet space, and held leadership roles at RedBus as Chief Operating Officer and Chief Product Officer. Earlier in his career, he spent over five years at Google, leading product management for Google Display Network and heading search and mobile products.

Ready to start your journey?

Fewer spreadsheets, faster planning, better decisions.

Book a Demo